Updated: Nov 5, 2020
Suet feeders hold cakes of fat embedded with various seeds, fruits, and insects. They are great for attracting a variety of birds, including woodpeckers and nuthatches!
Before we begin, there are two items I need to address:
All product links below lead to product listings on Amazon for your convenience. However, as an Amazon Associate, I do earn from qualifying purchases. I do not earn any commissions for recommending certain products, though.
Which Suet Feeder is Best?
Let's cut straight to the fat here... pause for laughter... If you spend more than $5 on a suet feeder, you have been had. This recommendation is easy because there is nothing complicated about a cage that holds a chunk of fat.
Best Overall Suet Feeder: C&S EZ Fill Suet Basket
This feeder is budget-friendly and effective. Don't be had. Be simple.
The Best Large Suet Feeder
However, if you have a large bird feeding budget...
Best Large Suet Feeder: Birds Choice 2-Cake Pileated Suet Feeder
If you have a lot of large woodpeckers visiting your feeder, you may want a larger suet feeder. This feeder holds two cakes and provides more room to large woodpeckers like the Pileated Woodpecker. You can hang this feeder, or use the large keel to attach it to a platform feeder or solid post. It is made from recycled poly lumber, so it will have a long lifespan. Plus, being made from recycled materials makes us all feel good, right? Regardless of the size, each suet feeder will attract an amazing variety of backyard birds.
Buy a Suet Log Feeder
If you are handy, consider making a suet log (see below). However, if you are not handy, there are several suet logs available for purchase.
Vertical Suet Log: Pine Tree Farms 2-Pack Suet Feeder
Horizontal Suet Log: Kettle Moraine Upside Down Suet Log
Between these feeders, the upside-down feeder is intriguing, as it can prevent starlings and other unfavorable species from using the feeder. While I typically feed birds on a budget, having a more natural suet feeder would be a win for taking photos at the feeder.
Build Your Own Suet Log Feeder
Suet feeders can be fairly easy to build! With a few simple steps, you build something like what is pictured below.
Find a downed tree or branch that is small to medium in diameter
Cut the log to a length of 12" or less
Drill 3-6 1 to 2" diameter holes in various places on the log
Hang your new log feeder
Which suet should I buy?
If you are unable to make your own suet, the options available can be overwhelming. Previously, I have used C&S Suet cakes that I buy in bulk. Specifically, I was using the Orange Suet Cake 12-pack (Amazon). However, I have recently attempted to switch to a suet cake that does not use artificial flavoring. Does artificial flavoring harm birds? We simply do not have a definitive answer. But, if I can find a cake that works without the artificial flavoring, then I will use it. And I have. From the depths of Amazon, I present to you the Heath Premium Crafted Suet Cakes. There are multiple flavors, but I am partial to the citrus cake. Word of WARNING. If you have been using 'suet dough' instead of real suet, then you will be in for a mess. Real suet is oily, melts easily, and can make a mess. But the birds will LOVE IT.
Best Overall 'Natural' Suet Cakes
Attract Birds with a Native Plant Garden!
A growing trend in North America is to take the 40+ million acres of turfgrass and turn it back into native plants and habitat. There are a number of organizations involved in this, but the National Audubon Society is one at the forefront of the movement. Native plants provide natural food sources that cannot be matched by bird feeders, especially in the breeding season. Why? Insects. Nestlings need insects for healthy growth, and insects (like caterpillars) need native plants.
Downy Woodpecker on Homemade Suet Log Feeder flickr photo by Trisha Shears, used under a Attribution-ShareAlike 2.0 Generic (CC BY-SA 2.0) license.