Northern Flicker Intergrades - Red-shafted vs Yellow-shafted Flickers
Get flicking.
The Northern Flicker, a common woodpecker found throughout North America, is often recognized by its brightly colored wings or ear-piercing screams (mostly banders and rehabbers experience this). Possibly, just possibly, you recognize them by the mango-sized holes, they leave in your eaves. (Until you placed a fake owl nearby, costing $19.99 plus tax from your local Home Depot. Then, said owl did not work, leaving a patchwork of boards screwed all over the sides of your home and a black hole of anger towards woodpeckers, in your heart.)
While the species might be easily recognized locally, bird-lovers from the east might not quickly decipher a Northern Flicker in the west. The reason? There are over eleven subspecies of Northern Flicker, and the two main subspecies groups for much of North America, look wildly different.
If you enjoy our work, if you hate our work, or if you merely tolerate our work, join the flock?
Northern Flicker Intergrade or Northern Flicker Hybrid?
Before we jump into the diluted Northern Flicker, let's review the definition of intergrade vs hybrid. An intergrade is the product of two subspecies or subspecies groups, and a hybrid is the product of two species. We discussed this in our post on Yellow-rumped Warbler intergrades, found here.
Which flicker do you have?
- Yellow-shafted
- Red-shafted
- Intergrade
- All 3
Two Northern Flicker Subspecies Groups
The two groups most birders are familiar with are the Yellow-shafted Northern Flicker (auratus group) and the Red-shafted Northern Flicker (cafer group). Those are the main focus of today's post, mostly because the average reader could care less about the other two groups. Moving your gaze downward, you will see a rudimentary breakdown of the range of each subspecies group in North America. The map gives you, the reader, an idea of what subspecies group you should expect to see on an average day in most of your state. Red state/province means you should expect red-shafted individuals and yellow state means you should expect yellow-shafted individuals.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Links may lead to affiliate sites.
Take your own flicker images!
Need more camera recommendations? Check out our camera suggestions!
What gives a flicker red-shafted, yellow-shafted, or intergrade coloration?
The Red-shafted and Yellow-shafted Northern Flickers share a genome that is over 99% identical. However, the 0.01% difference in DNA between the two groups is all that is required to have significant differences in appearance! How do we know this? Research performed by Stepfanie Aguillon from the Cornell Lab of Ornithology! Just a handful of genes drive the major color differences we see in the Northern Flicker. Insert mind-blown emoji here.
Map of Red-shafted, Yellow-shafted, and Intergrade Flickers
If you are curious about what the giant orange blob represents, it is an oblivion of knowledge. A succubus of hopeful identification. It is the zone of intergradation. The zone of intergradation is the area where these two subspecies groups meet, copulate, and produce babies that will not fit nicely into either group. It likely extends the entire range of the meeting line of the two subspecies groups. However, the map above shows documented intergrades.
If the zone of intergradation scares you, fear no more! Or just fear slightly less. I am here to tell you about the infinite possibilities of morphological characteristics found in intergrades.
First, you need to know what base characteristics can distinguish the two subspecies groups.
Four Base Characteristics for the Northern Flicker Subspecies
Malar Color
Face Color
Nape Pattern
Flight Feather Color (Wing & tail)
Field Mark | Red-shafted Group (male) | Yellow-shafted Group (male) | Red-shafted Group (female) | Yellow-shafted Group (female) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Yellow | Red | Black | Buffy | No malar stripe |
Face Color | Gray | Buffy to warm, light brown | Gray | Buffy to warm, light brown |
Nape Pattern | None | Red Crescent | None | Red Crescent |
Feather Color (wing/tail) | Pinkish to reddish to red | Yellow | Pinkish to reddish to red | Yellow |
Those four characteristics are straightforward for non-intergrades. Now, look at some of the possibilities for an intergrade.
Field Mark | Intergrade Northern Flicker (male) | Intergrade Northern Flicker (female) |
Malar Color | Red, black, red+black | Buffy, none |
Face Color | Gray, buffy, gray+buffy | Gray, buffy, gray+buffy |
Nape Pattern | Red crescent, none | Red crescent, none |
Feather Color (wing/tail) | Red, yellow, reddish, orange, yellow+orange, yellow+red | Red, yellow, reddish, orange, yellow+orange, yellow+red |
OOOFF. That was a sucker punch! Absolutely zero help. You should just quit reading now. ORRR, check out these examples from the zone of intergradation! They may just shed a little light on this pit of despair we have found ourselves in.
Photos of Red-shafted, Yellow-shafted, and Intergrade Flickers
Look at these two Northern Flicker Intergrades. The left individual has a black malar stripe, gray face, faint red crescent, and orangeish-yellow flight feathers. The right individual has a red malar stripe, red crescent, buffy face, and orangish-red flight feathers.
Photo breakdown:
Photo 1 - See a full breakdown below.
Photo 2 - Look at the photo showing the napes (back of the head/neck). Note the varying amount of red crescent that is visible. This is a trait from the Yellow-shafted Northern Flicker. However, these individuals have traits that do not agree with our chart above for a Yellow-shafted Northern Flicker.
Photo 3 - This wing is from the right bird (red malar). Note that it is slightly more orange than yellow.
Photo 4 - This wing is from the left bird (black malar). It is more yellow than orange.
Want to attract woodpeckers? Use suet!
If you want to attract woodpeckers, like the Northern Flicker, to your home, then consider feeding suet in your backyard! The suet cake below is made from natural ingredients with no artificial flavoring.
Be honest. If you saw the left bird in the first photo, with the black malar, fly by very quickly, would you consider it a Yellow-shafted Flicker? I would. Especially without photos! How do we know from these photos that it is an intergrade? Join me on a jaunt through our four points:
Malar - Black
Face - Gray
Nape - Red Crescent (faint)
Feathers - Orangeish-yellow
Two features stand out on the right bird, face color and feather color. On a true Yellow-shafted Flicker, we would expect a warm, buffy face. Additionally, the flight feathers would be more true yellow. The right bird should be more obvious, but I will walk through that bird as well:
Malar - Red
Face - Buffy
Nape - Red Crescent
Feathers - Yellowish-orange
Ready to try your own birds? Here are three individuals for you to try your newfound skills on! Answers to this quiz can be found below.
Quiz Answers
Bird 1 - Intergrade - Bi-colored malar, red nape markings, gray face with buffy edging, and orange flight feathers
Bird 2 - Intergrade - Bi-colored malar, buffy face
Bird 3 - Intergrade - Buffy malar, grayish face, yellow-ish flight feathers
Improve your woodpecker ID skills with the Peterson Reference Guide to Woodpeckers of North America!
Our favorite woodpecker guide:
I hope this was a helpful article on Northern Flicker intergrades! Have questions or information to add? Use the comment section below or reach out to us!
Want more tips on birds, feeding birds, identifying birds, wildlife safety, and more?? Join our site, join us on Flocking YouTube, like us on Facebook, follow us on Instagram, and Twitter, and visit our Amazon Storefront.
