Which birdseed is best for attracting birds? - A Guide for Buying Bird Food

Updated: Apr 13

Bird food should not be bought haphazardly. Our guide will prevent you from wasting money on waste foods. If you missed our guide to feeders, click here!

Feeding birds is a $4+ billion industry. How has this industry become such a powerhouse? People wasting dollars on foods that mostly become waste. How do you know you are not shopping correctly for bird food?

You buy food based on the "cover birds." - Many bags of birdseed put photos of birds on the cover that you have no chance of attracting. Often, seed bags have birds found in the UK on the cover of seed sold in North America. Ouch.

You buy food with "Deluxe Blend" or "Wild Bird Food," instead of reading the ingredients. - If you see a bag of bird food with "Deluxe Blend," R-U-N! A deluxe blend equals a deluxe waste of money. If you buy a deluxe blend, all you are doing is supporting a CEO's deluxe lifestyle. STOP! Simplify.

You look for the cheapest bag you can find. - Does buying the cheapest item available ever work out? If you are feeding on a budget, buy smaller bags of the good stuff and put your birds on a RATION! That's right, give those piggies a diet. Put the limited food out on a schedule and train those little feathered blighters when to arrive and provide enjoyment.

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Product links below may lead to Amazon or other affiliate sites.

The best birdseed for attracting birds

We do not flock around when it comes to recommendations. Our recommendations are safe, healthy for birds, and provide value for the investment. However, our food recommendations are not brand-based, but instead, we base our recommendation on FOOD TYPE. Without feather ado, let's begin. Different food types can attract different birds. Alter the foods you offer to attract a larger variety of birds! What are our top birdseed recommendations? Here they are:

Best Overall Birdseed: Sunflower Seed

Sunflower seed is the best all-around birdseed you can buy. It attracts woodpeckers, nuthatches, chickadees, tits, cardinals, grosbeaks, buntings, sparrows, finches, and more! Sunflower seeds are a great source of fat, fiber, protein, calcium, and several other vitamins and minerals.

Click here to see it on Amazon!

The best way to buy sunflower seed is in a local feed, hardware, or gardening store. You can often buy in bulk, lessening your cost per pound. However, if you cannot buy in a local store, the Wagner's 25 lb Black Oil Sunflower Seed from Amazon is not outrageously priced. But again, buying in-store will likely provide you the best value.

What birds does sunflower seed attract?

Sunflower seed attracts the largest variety of birds. Big and small, almost all birds are willing to feed at a trough full of sunflower seeds. Here are just some of the birds that sunflower seed will attract:

  • Cardinals

  • Chickadees

  • Finches

  • Juncos

  • Jays

  • Nuthatches

  • Titmice

  • Sparrows

  • Magpies

  • Woodpeckers

  • Crows

  • Turkeys

  • Quail

  • and more!

How you present the food will also determine which species are attracted. Obviously, a quail is unlikely to visit a hanging feeder, but instead, would eat at a platform feeder on the ground.

The Best Finch Seed: Nyjer or Thistle Seed

Nyjer seed, also called thistle seed, is a great attractant for finches, juncos, and other species of sparrows. While it is also called thistle, it is not related to the noxious thistle plants found in North America. Additionally, nyjer seed is heated to prevent germination if the seeds fall to the ground. Finches love it, especially in winter, as it is a great source of fat and protein. Want to learn more about nyjer seed? Visit our special post on this very topic!

Click here to see it on Amazon!

Again, the best way to purchase nyjer seed is in a local feed, hardware, or gardening store. You can often buy in bulk, lessening your cost per pound. If that is not possible, Wagner's Nyjer Seed is a decent deal.

What birds does Nyjer seed attract?

Nyjer seed is a great alternative to sunflower seed if you are getting too many pest species such as squirrels and House Sparrows. Why? They do not prefer nyjer seed, even though it is in the sunflower family. So, what birds do love to eat nyjer seed?

  • Finches

  • Chickadees

  • Juncos

  • Titmice

  • Sparrows

Birdseed to deter House Sparrows, European Starlings, and squirrels?

Safflower seed is often pointed to by bird-lovers who struggle with European Starlings or squirrels mobbing their feeders. However, it may not discourage all "pests" for long. Is it worth a try if your feeders are overrun with starlings? Absolutely. However, it can be an expensive alternative.

Click here to see it on Amazon!

Not all local stores will carry safflower seed. If they do, you will likely find a better deal with those stores. However, if your stores do not carry it, trying a small bag like Wagner's Safflower Seed may be worth a try.

What is the best suet?

Suet is a great food option for attracting woodpeckers, nuthatches, chickadees, jays, and even the occasional warbler. It is best used in cooler months, as the suet can get soft or melt during the summer. Here at Flocking Around, we feed multiple kinds of seed. So, when we put out suet cakes, we prefer those that have foods not included in our regularly provided menu. For us, that includes berries, mealworms, and peanuts.

Heath All Natural Orange Suet

Click here to see it on Amazon!

C&S Orange Suet Dough

Click here to see it on Amazon!

Most local garden, feed, and hardware stores offer a variety of suets. However, if they do not, here is a link to investigate the many options available online: Suet.

Homemade Hummingbird Food

Please, please, please, DO NOT USE RED DYE! If you do not believe you have the time to make your own hummingbird food, then plant flowers that attract hummingbirds. Purchasing hummingbird food with red dyes is not helping birds. DO NOT DO IT.

Now, to make your own hummingbird food, follow these steps:

  1. Mix 1 part sugar with 4 parts water (for example, 1 cup of sugar with 4 cups of water) until the sugar is dissolved - Make sure to only use REFINED WHITE SUGAR - Do not use honey


  3. Fill your hummingbird feeder with homemade food

  4. Extra hummingbird food can be stored in a refrigerator

Here at Flocking Around, we make enough food to last for several weeks, and then we store it in sealed glass jars. If you are worried about the time required for making food, this is a great way to be prepared. Of course, the whole process takes less than 10 minutes, but we still won't discourage a well-prepped birdwatcher!

Top Plants for Feeding Birds

Native plants are often the best way to support birds. Plants provide food by the insects that feed upon them in summer, and then often they provide food through berries or seeds after the growing season has finished. The best way to find out which native plants are great for attracting and helping birds in your area is to use the National Audubon Society's Native Plant Database. However, this database can oversimplify if you know your plants. So, if you have a good grasp of plants and gardening, visit the North American Plant Atlas of the Biota of North America Program.

How to buy birdseed

DO NOT BUY MIXED SEED. - That is the most important advice I can offer. Buy one or a combination of the three types of seed offered in this guide: sunflower, Nyjer, millet. It will attract more birds and waste less money than any other option.

Feeding birds can be an enjoyable experience and hobby. However, it can require serious effort and research! We hope this guide helps reduce the time required for the preparation of feeding birds. We also hope we saved you from wasting money on the multitude of waste birdseed on the market.

If you enjoy these flocking posts, register for blog notifications, like us on Facebook, follow us on Instagram and Twitter, and visit our Amazon Storefront.